Sony defeats £2bn PlayStation Store claim – what it means for Great Park gamers

A white and black DualSense controller for PlayStation 5

A DualSense controller for PlayStation 5. Photo: Sergey Galyonkin via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Great Park PlayStation players who bought downloadable games or add-ons won’t receive compensation under today’s ruling. The Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed a UK claim worth nearly £2 billion against Sony on Tuesday 17 November.

The case, led by consumer campaigner Alex Neill, covered about 12.2 million people. For qualifying buyers in England, including Newcastle, it covered purchases from 19 August 2016 to 12 February 2026. The total sought was equivalent to roughly £162 per person if divided evenly across the group. The tribunal has awarded no payment. Read the tribunal’s summary.

Why the case failed

Neill’s team argued Sony used its control of the PlayStation Store to keep competing digital shops off the console and charge too much for games and add-ons. The judgment says Sony agrees wholesale prices with publishers, sets the store price and typically targets a 30% margin on digital games. The claim compared digital prices with disc prices and argued that rival digital shops could have brought prices down by about 20%.

Sony said it had spent years and billions building a platform that benefits players. It argued that PlayStation competes with Xbox and Nintendo, which operate similar stores. The tribunal looked at competition between gaming systems, including what players pay for consoles and games. It found that the prospect of players switching systems constrained Sony’s prices and that the claim had failed to establish either unlawful conduct or the projected 20% price cut.

Could there be an appeal?

Neill said her team is considering whether to appeal. The tribunal plans a hearing in the week beginning 14 December to deal with costs and any applications for permission to appeal. Read the class representative’s response.

What Great Park players can check before buying

If you’re buying a PS4 or PS5 game in Great Park, compare the same edition in the UK PlayStation Store with a new or second-hand disc if your console has a drive. Sony’s Black Friday sale runs until 30 November, with some offers ending sooner. See PlayStation’s sale details.

There’s a bigger change ahead for anyone who lends, trades or buys used games. Sony says it will stop producing discs for newly released PlayStation games from January 2028. New releases will be sold digitally through the PlayStation Store and retailers. Existing disc releases will still work on compatible consoles. Read Sony’s announcement about game discs.

Have your say

Do you buy games digitally or wait for a deal on disc? Share how you shop in the Great Park Residents Group.

Previous
Previous

TalkTalk website caught up in cyberattack – what Great Park residents should check

Next
Next

Morrisons Great Park Black Friday deals include £35 coffee machine and £8 gift sets